A Thief In The Night Hogwarts Legacy Quest Walkthrough And Rewards

2 November 2026 | 85

Exploring the open world of Hogwarts Legacy leads players to numerous side quests scattered across the Highlands. Among these intriguing side missions is A Thief in the Night, a quest involving mysterious disappearances in the hamlet of Feldcroft. Understanding how to initiate this mission and track down the elusive culprit ensures players earn valuable gear and complete their regional quest logs.

How to Start the Quest in Feldcroft

To unlock A Thief in the Night, players must first complete the main storyline quest titled High Keep. Once this prerequisite is met, head to the hamlet of Feldcroft located in the southern region of the world map. Speak with the merchant named Padraic Haggarty during the daytime to hear about his stolen family heirloom and recent village thefts.

Padraic suspects his own sister of stealing the items, but investigating the scene requires waiting until nightfall. Players can easily advance the in-game clock by opening the map screen and selecting the wait option. Once night descends, casting Revelio near the merchant's stall reveals a trail of glowing coins left behind by the culprit.

Following the Gold Coin Trail

Tracking the thief requires following the trail of dropped Galleons leading out of the village toward the western cliffs. Players should cast Revelio continuously to keep the glowing coin footprints highlighted along the path. The trail leads through rocky terrain and past minor enemy camps, so staying alert during the nighttime navigation is essential.

Eventually, the path ends at a hidden cave entrance tucked beneath a cliffside near the water's edge. Entering the cave reveals a massive hoard of shiny objects, confirming that the thief is actually a creature driven by a obsession with glittery treasures. Preparing your Nab-Sack before stepping further into the den ensures a smooth rescue operation.

Capturing the Niffler and Quest Rewards

Inside the cave, players discover that the village thief is a mischievous Niffler hoarding gold and trinkets. Equipping the Nab-Sack spell allows players to safely capture the creature while it wanders around its treasure pile. After securing the Niffler, search the top of the central gold pile to retrieve Padraic Haggarty's stolen heirloom.

Return to Feldcroft and speak with Padraic to complete the quest and decide the fate of the heirloom. Successfully turning in the quest rewards players with experience points, gold coins, and the Niffler Mask cosmetic item. Keeping or returning the heirloom alters minor dialogue options without impacting overall story progression.